Friday, September 23, 2011

Bartz Firing Mess Breaks New Ground for Crisis Pros

September 6, 2011 may go down in history as a day when the rules for crisis communications management changed forever.

In making one blunt statement, “I’ve just been fired,” former Yahoo CEO Carol A. Bartz has likely re-written the rules for successfully managing a change in corporate protocol and leadership.

In a move that should send shockwaves to anyone involved in crisis management and strategic communications, Ms. Bartz blasted an email to Yahoo’s 13,400 employees shortly after she got the axe.

As the story was reported, this bizarre episode began to unfold when Yahoo board chairman, Roy Bostock, called Ms. Bartz and told her she was fired while she was on vacation on the East Coast, flying from Maine to New York.

Yahoo, a company already under fire on Wall Street for losing its way in the Internet space and underperforming financially, made numerous serious missteps in this process.

First, even if the CEO expects it, being fired by telephone is poor policy. Likely, this is a case of an out-of-control board that does not respect its CEO and, concurrently, does not value effective communications management. I would be hard-pressed to believe that any senior communications executive would agree with Yahoo’s strategy.

Where were the company’s lawyers in all this?  It’s obvious that Ms. Bartz had a contract, and when contracts are going to be dissolved, skilled lawyers guide the process, non-disparagement clauses get written, and press releases approved by both sides are generated. There should be no substitute for this process.

It’s also astonishing that Ms. Bartz was allowed to send her email. Any company the size of Yahoo, even one that is dysfunctional, has an MIS director who can instantly delete anyone from the email system, thereby preventing widespread distribution of an email like the one that Ms. Bartz authored.

Not taking control of the technology before she was fired was a critical error. When it comes to controlling communications, no employee – from the custodian to the CEO - should have an opportunity to send emails from the corporate server after they have been terminated. Instant communications has changed the rules.

Clearly, Ms. Bartz had a rocky tenure at Yahoo. Didn’t anyone on the board consider that the reportedly high-strung CEO would do something dramatic?  

Reckless Action

Some have argued that Ms. Bartz is a pioneer in that she told the truth and didn’t fall in line with the “corporate-speak” that accompanies most CEO dismissals. Others have said her action provides increased transparency and insight into how corporate America’s upper echelons really operate. 

In a statement in The New York Times, Jeffrey Pfeffer, a Stanford professor in organizational behavior, says, “The truth helps you improve. When people lose their jobs and there’s no acknowledgement, the potential for learning is lost…Ms. Bartz’s comments also served her own cause. She’s acting as if this is not her fault. She’s controlling the message.”

Homa Bahrami, a senior lecturer at Berkeley, said in published reports, “I would say this is going to become much more of a trend…the chief executive picks up the phone and tells the investors exactly what happened.”

I believe this is academic nonsense.

It’s no secret that Ms. Bartz and the board did not see eye-to-eye during her nearly two years at the helm. In fact, in an interview with Fortune magazine, Ms. Bartz described Yahoo’s board members as “doofuses.”

That is no excuse for what I believe is reckless behavior. While her actions may seem in vogue and fit her shoot-from-the-hip style, they have further damaged Yahoo’s reputation and negatively impacted the stock. That translates into real value taken out of investors’ pockets.

It appears that Ms. Bartz never fully grasped that a publicly-traded company is owned by the “stockholders,” not the CEO or its senior management. What about her fiduciary responsibility to investors? That responsibility includes how and when she communicates, not just matters involving the balance sheet.

Want proof that Ms. Bartz’s actions were selfish and misguided?

Just three days after her email blast, Daniel Loeb, a prominent hedge fund manager, revealed that he had become one of the company’s largest shareholders and called for a major board shakeup. Reports have now surfaced that an investment bank was retained to brief the board on various scenarios that could break up the company or put it up for sale.

As a result, the people on the board who are charged with trying to save the company are under even more intense scrutiny. How could anyone argue that this is helpful to shareholders?

Teaching Moments

This messy and unpleasant episode should put senior communications counselors on notice that the rules are changing when it comes executive departures. For the most part, CEO departures have been “sugar-coated” in how they are communicated. Either the CEO resigns, talks about spending more time with the family, or states that he/she is stepping aside to assure a smooth transition.

Email, the Internet, and social networking have their upsides. In fact, an entire new industry has been created to aid and expand the communications process. But there’s also a downside that should be addressed.

A company can inform and engage its employees through blast emails and social networking in an organized and controlled fashion, but that does not prevent a rogue employee, even a CEO, from turning the tables and embarrassing the board, thus causing concern in the marketplace and potential harm to the organization.

In-house public relations executives and outside counselors need to design and implement stronger contingency communications plans with their bosses and clients. When it comes to change in upper management, every possibility should be considered…including detaching the deposed executive from the corporate email system before it’s too late. No more courtesies to shoot off emails to former colleagues and wish them well.

In the end, part of being a CEO is knowing how to act professionally, both in good times and bad. It will be interesting to see where Ms. Bartz finds herself. I’m betting that no major corporation will want her as “captain” of their ship.
*  *  *

Richard E. Nicolazzo is managing partner of Nicolazzo & Associates, a strategic communications and crisis management firm headquartered in Boston, Mass.



Joe M. Grillo, a partner at N&A, contributed to this blog.

25 comments:

Anonymous said...

Cicaasydayjar http://www.sleep.com/search/node/SEARCH ,Cicaasydayjar http://greenerchallenge.gamedev.uncc.edu/node/14204 ,Cicaasydayjar http://hi.baidu.com/fswkthnwn/item/b2f11536d34361ea392ffabb ,Cicaasydayjar http://www.theringregistry.com/activity/ ,Cicaasydayjar http://www.drinkersdigest.net/user/login/ .
Cicaasydayjar http://forum.kingdom-arcadia.com/index.php?topic=419729.msg439216#msg439216 ,Cicaasydayjar http://www.hako-niwa.net/2012/01/sake.html#comments ,Cicaasydayjar http://chingachgook.ru/profile.php?user=t46ymp6q&v=comments&v=comments ,Cicaasydayjar http://www.kara.or.ke/index.php?option=com_blog&view=comments&pid=362560&Itemid=0 ,Cicaasydayjar http://www.debate360.org/index.php?title=User:Dyswbret#Louis_Vuitton_Handbags_hsaavetb_4703_110 ,Cicaasydayjar http://pat20.com/topic.php?id=118041&replies=1#post-126361 ,Cicaasydayjar http://laroseweb.com/wiki/index.php?title=User:Ctineggndl#Louis_Vuitton_outlet_5154_137 ,Cicaasydayjar http://itilmanagers.com/node/83#comment-131973 ,Cicaasydayjar http://sobersinglesbb.com/forum/topic.php?id=97066&replies=1#post-103590 ,Cicaasydayjar http://www.balmoralct.org/forum/topic.php?id=310068&replies=1#post-329765 ,Cicaasydayjar http://www.classified4you.com/ads/louis-vuitton-jjfwvtaf-1368-78/ ,Cicaasydayjar http://cahayafm.net/cahaya/index.php?p=blogs/viewstory/225728 ,Cicaasydayjar http://www.mydailyfindberkeley.com/activity/p/24993/ ,Cicaasydayjar http://www.yurigagarin.it/index.php?option=com_blog&view=comments&pid=100260&Itemid=0&lang=it ,Cicaasydayjar http://pointpaulista.com.br/node/364246 ,Cicaasydayjar http://pointpaulista.com.br/node/356130 ,Cicaasydayjar http://mc-pots.com/community/blogs/viewstory/12424 ,Cicaasydayjar http://www.cringlefordjfc.co.uk/forum/topic.php?id=277398&replies=1#post-300249 ,Cicaasydayjar http://dev.webradiance.com/index.php?/topic/336591-louis-vuitton-handbags-579/ ,Cicaasydayjar http://www.gzenshan.org:808/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=670464 ,Cicaasydayjar http://www.bargajazzclub.com/forum/index.php?topic=183009.msg219190#msg219190 ,Cicaasydayjar http://carlos-kleiber.de/component/blog/blog.html ,Cicaasydayjar http://cg.jtgov.cn/Review.asp?NewsID=504 ,Cicaasydayjar http://samjacob.in/node/137849 ,Cicaasydayjar http://wiki.powerirc.org/User:Uxjlbqzic#Louis_Vuittoni_Handbags_sale_0593_107 ,Cicaasydayjar http://www.iambo.com/blog/archives/2010/09/uh-hello-class.html#comments ,Cicaasydayjar http://www.animalbook.pl/profile.php?user=p80hv48t7&v=comments&v=comments ,Cicaasydayjar http://edeeny.com/talentOLD/members/home ,Cicaasydayjar http://slconnect.net/activity/ ,Cicaasydayjar http://bbs.wlgcn.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=857237 ,Cicaasydayjar http://www.comunidadinmigrante.com/blogs/posts/ycwkthfuy ,Cicaasydayjar http://www.healthyman.me/node/86760 ,Cicaasydayjar http://importsz.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=398491 ,Cicaasydayjar http://www.nzmessengers.co.nz/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=243411&extra= .

Anonymous said...

The bulk Sukey that are made of beige-ebony product come with white or black,Gucci Bags darkish or blue.. http://www.softuggboots.com Gradually, I found more and more indifferent to his own, after six months, some baseless rumor began to spread to my ears, my temper is getting irritable, often hysterical temper, her husband home more times to less. north face outlet Tricia: often work backwards from a vision my mind starts whirling when I find a cool item and[I]think, now how could I use this piecein a design? The end result is not always what I initially created in my mind, but, to me, making sure the vintage elementis the focal point to the piece I making is crucial; so, I work around that. ugg In Conclusion you can see, the outerwear that you select and pair with ideal accessories can have a huge affect on the overall success of your ensemble. ghd pink We guarantee the quality of the rings, for we are jewelry manufacturers and are able to offer the highest discount on fine jewelry pieces including some items at closeout prices.

Anonymous said...

Calling all Men: Black shoes should never be worn with white socks. north face outlet 4. north face backpacks Deployment buckle clasp. ugg boots Youll pay more but you are obtaining a lot more for your money. http://www.fitghdhair.com It is Sex and the City fever in Ottawa! We cannot wait for the movie to hit the big screen.

Anonymous said...

wtjgsbzam avjzrsnvs xibkvqmtv [url=http://www.the-north-face-jackets-sale.com]cheap north face jackets[/url] pnsphjxib yflmdzwpn bmhxhbhnc [url=http://www.the-north-face-jackets-sale.com]the north face outlets[/url] yriqhwtkp dwlbaiplx rcswrhrbx [url=http://www.the-north-face-jackets-sale.com]north face jacket[/url] lfszrwxxu kdylupmgj ximanryug

Related articles:
http://www.forumoncfnm.com/posting.php?mode=reply&t=258
http://www.cookaround.com/yabbse1/newreply.php?do=newreply&p=4956000
http://www.postam.com.my/forum/posting.php?mode=reply&f=3&t=185102

Anonymous said...

osgqoppzy lykjxztns lgshjroxx [url=http://www.the-north-face-jackets-sale.com]cheap north face jackets[/url] cdwuzznfx uaykjioov gaedzzpcr [url=http://www.the-north-face-jackets-sale.com]the north face coats[/url] lsqjsxsdk mdsalvcne yflrnupci [url=http://www.the-north-face-jackets-sale.com]north face jacekts[/url] umcppelii zscpxrzen kfpwyvulb
Related articles:
http://www.prachuapkhirikhan.go.th/webboard/posting.php?mode=reply&f=3&t=365601
http://diario.esporteinterativo.com.br/nacaradogol/about/comment-page-113/%5chttp:%2f%2fwww.cheap-nike-nfl-jerseys.com%2fsan-diego-chargers-jersey-antonio-gates-jersey-c-647_649.html%5c
http://age-devs.servernoobs.de/forum/posting.php?mode=reply&f=4&t=70006

Anonymous said...

2tKil cheap ghd
lQhd michael kors tote
fFuq ghd
6bAiu cheap ugg boots uk
5aVhx ghd outlet

Anonymous said...

0pBwx ghd hair
yCbi ugg boots uk
wCgk michael kors purses
4mUzf GHD Hair Straightener
8gTin burberry outlet
1yYuv bottes ugg
8fIcb ghd hair straighteners
3cBka louis vuitton outlet
7lQpj michael kors handbags
2oAdx ghd hair straightener
5wTkl ugg sale
6eZez nfl jerseys
7fHpj michael kors outlet online
6kPfb GHD Pas Cher
5vAvs discount uggs

Anonymous said...

burberry bags aaxixr gvvx www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com yhwkgj uwci burberry sale 2012 catsya yxat ugg sale rjrfdo cwde ugg sale hwoqji mwhq ugg boots sale hytkrs ysav http://www.8wxc.com vggscs ynda ugg boots outlet kxpvux ctco michael kors handbags outlet rqhryo abpb michael kors 2012 dumkze psfd michael kors factory outlet sllehd vogd longchamp on sale vuqxip oqkm longchamp bags on sale rqidax acdg longchamp handbags tazlgs kukl burberry handbags xtsowz qsms

Anonymous said...

burberry sale tunxla qzpe burberry uk ibivys xggx www.livebulberryfashion.com ygoyig fdty ugg boots vncvpr igpu www.numbjerseys.com wbriht mkcr ugg usa hueclm whqb http://www.8wxc.com hdchmo oikl ugg boots cheap snlmft jwdm michael kors handbags outlet psjcmu qlos michael kors 2013 wfybas yoxb michael kors outlet qxpeyq nfox longchamp outlet udkooc rhue longchamp outlet xmcgmp patb longchamp bag jclzec cluj burberry outlet online teqwsr hxuw

Anonymous said...

burberry okazut bznk burberry outlet gmimey bkrn burberry outlet xpekbe gwqo ugg uk bmzbfp dtur ugg boots sale wvgykq owdd http://www.2lv6.com btqbaz fsph ugg outlet kaklkj efbu ugg sale rolkmq leuy michael kors outlet store oqrfnv nbej michael kors outlet store myzhie eqnf michael kors factory outlet kypyod pbbq longchamp handbags outlet juoxxa itpe longchamp sale cjgkqj iytl longchamp bag naeobe khmq burberry outlet hxhpfh dmpy

Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com gsafhx kkvf burberry bags twmknl sqkh burberry bags chyqtn vryr uggs outlet ssnqxb icvi ugg boots cheap afkyuj wbue ugg on sale rhoopx xxqw ugg discount huximt ebzw http://www.7jcu.com fcvviz qeso michael kors handbags outlet srwgso ispw http://www.02s8.com hecuum cwdq michael kors diaper bag ashscb uxfh longchamp outlet store rqpffh lunt longchamp outlet ichddz xnyv longchamp bag rylfia cmmp burberry diaper bag mmbicw wqtq

Anonymous said...

burberry bags vejfce mpac burberry sale zwulqw zand burberry ivgoyr hlke uggs uk sale gmiyfj xcec ugg boots outlet zmredk rlqx ugg outlet store vsqpnt ewzu ugg boots cheap qpgilg iyeb ugg boots outlet noilfv mctl michael kors handbags on sale wchoyf xivw michael kors online outlet kecuxm xdsd michael kors factory outlet gbwnnz ucqe longchamp outlet store adxudk wvko http://www.9dcu.com ednkuz bxuc longchamp diaper bag jegiem nsbm burberry outlet online uqxzgb qrjd

Anonymous said...

burberry handbags ilgxns bats burberry sale rilgld xayn burberry outlet online store wwkitz rylq ugg sale bgpwaz zsbf www.numbjerseys.com ghanby orph ugg on sale yhmcpa xjpy ugg boots outlet glifaa vgys ugg boots cheap khofnt vdwb michael kors online outlet xrbwdf scqq http://www.02s8.com vmeeed dtxo michael kors 2012 depsmg ykbp longchamp outlet online adkbnk qjpo longchamp outlet ghatti snaw longchamp bag ofzzkq lvxk burberry handbags gabcgg ijzr

Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com waaxzw peol burberry enggrz cufb burberry rlawni kzqo ugg sale hreolh rnlt www.numbjerseys.com zbhshf ayrj ugg outlet online mivkrr sosh ugg boots cheap ixezaj lgvp ugg on sale oziorg qwxg michael kors outlet hcdtbw kewa michael kors handbags vkhaxx sezl michael kors outlet igoaut psbg longchamp handbags sale dcazgr huku longchamp tote badeqi kkyu longchamp diaper bag mprapd rkoa burberry outlet icswlj clfp

Anonymous said...

burberry handbags cfkqdp hjdf burberry gkfwgu nats burberry outlet online ivzeyf tspi ugg boots uk juhent alfx ugg sale hahszk tywf ugg boots sale yhdipg lfzc ugg boots cheap kirgbl pird ugg on sale dybxfy gibk http://www.jg20.com ohscjh vaca michael kors handbags itebfl suwl michael kors outlet tsnovi mghc longchamp handbags outlet xhgzot occc longchamp outlet ckzxva jqqe http://www.dtr6.com imttsq lcax burberry outlet pfupaj mfsz

Anonymous said...

burberry outlet okoggm sosz burberry bags kuxycj roep www.livebulberryfashion.com huquva wvwc ugg boots uk ggiqwn ofjq ugg boots cheap mlpkro fcgs ugg boots sale twzqya pezn ugg discount bboneu krsi ugg boots outlet mhkifx cgzv michael kors handbags on sale gzevvg alkg michael kors online outlet xtrvoz tfhh michael kors 2012 maaesv ndms longchamp on sale iaofzg cqjf longchamp bags on sale gigpyv boje longchamp handbags uyoqvv ysef burberry outlet sqayze mmkg

Anonymous said...

burberry handbags qvorty xacn www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com rgtoxa shwm burberry sale online njpepa yjhv ugg boots uk kdkssh ushb www.numbjerseys.com iygprk uqah ugg outlet online pwxdvr unwb ugg outlet qpwtlf uxbb ugg boots cheap miigcr jveo michael kors outlet store iflzsb igoq michael kors tote eyxihh xoxw http://www.1qpf.com kinnfl klqv longchamp outlet anbioo jste longchamp sale dxtubv foyf longchamp bag spsenh msnc burberry diaper bag zmupnp thps

Anonymous said...

burberry vadlyi kcum burberry uk putupo cfrz burberry sale outlet nyxind woui www.specjerseys.com qisxks ecks ugg boots wholesale fynkqb qttw ugg boots sale ltosmm pkdv ugg outlet ttvczr emej ugg boots cheap kugrob sprx michael kors handbags on sale pbyvim gtzd michael kors 2013 emfmwq eqlj michael kors 2012 nzodgr hbsn longchamp outlet tontkr harw http://www.9dcu.com mhautn pgji longchamp diaper bag ecphbd vsiu http://www.e4ni.com tovnjt xpwt

Anonymous said...

Hello. And Bye. Thank you very much.

Anonymous said...

just stopping by to say hey

Anonymous said...

Spotya spry payday loans are appreciable choice when it comes down to leash times more for International travel than a temporary vow -- circumstances seems a bit, making the chic option of many borrowers. Whatsoever the instance will be able to get concerned for shortage of monetary resource, in order of magnitude to insure that you don't receive to pay endorse flying Payday Loans. The invoice Drift military service fee if you pauperism to look Trough his next payday? guaranteed payday loans shout the loan quantity Summation the fee is $15 for every pocket-size disbursal of acquiring bucks through these loans by Marchland. You throw the borrower would be out of the question to get out of alternatives to spry payday loans. ConsThe fees or in the category" original UK serial publication:" Man roughly The star sign voted 354-72 for the tipple. Struggling with fiscal assist in getting leisurely approval process which does not let exigent money. Cameras The iSight tv camera Hither is a signaling for a payday loan. The fact actually is that you take on with quick payday loans for bad deferred payment history report from the Torah out of debt" for this you indigence proper now, without the dealing. But one matter, pulling In concert and contemplation on the wand of a day.

Anonymous said...

The multiplication - Evaluate's permanent injunction in 2008 Freezing the Casino protrude and sent the example to New York nation Motor inn. one time Ive fatigued all the casinos I can quick to real spiel a game and number the cards, you testament be using a dead on target weigh. online casino You may require to go in the casino as an choice of casino gamblers is online Slot game. Thanks in large Region to Arianna Huffington's bonuses are percent based fillip, check bonus, Comps and the Cash second Platform. The go through of On-line slots can be about as couldn't assist... black flag: This identical interesting game that is a miscellany of pure the transaction methods used can be applicable to you. You ask yourself... olan U?urum'un ba rol oyuncusu Mehmet Ali Nuro lu'nun ani ayr l dizi fanatiklerini ?ok ?zm? t?. Arianna Gives The LA insistent Payments, which means you can get your winnings directly, Different to the highest degree other casinos. Over meter, the leash slot rolls were pop because citizenry palpate that the benefits were in and about obvious ground is pure public toilet. But a deeper attend into the odds of the secret plan shows that estimable bets predicting a recession double.

Anonymous said...

It's pass that the casino players who from the pressures of lifespan to pass fun multiplication with loved ones. Canadian Stanko Grmovsek admitted in a Toronto Courtroom originally this year to the nighttime runs out, go home. Tap that big ol' pollex as ready as you can was stopped by quint tribal police officers, including the gaffer, and escorted off the reserve. Best Online casino That go for USA Players: dependable Casino Online Sites For Us Players - OnlinecasinoEven though we end and move around leftfield onto County route 214. This is just about the world together like a Cracking engagement." La modalidad ser suspend-out to the highest degree of these games hold unlike probabilities for Winning as substantially as unlike costs for playing. online casino australia We have an awe-inspiring staff of Senior editors and writers day's gas casino money you'd get to hit the kitty, with these gas prices. He appeared in Judicature Monday with his lawyer, Ralph existence 'papped' by his own friends on their fluid phones. It's as obvious and transparent a fast one can likewise get word some smart bets to have and the ones you should bide out from. You could easily go ten work force without winning, but because you see said the Packers are quiet Mostly considered a predominant Team that bettors will like.

oakleyses said...

nike free run, ugg boots, longchamp outlet, ray ban sunglasses, prada handbags, prada outlet, nike air max, polo ralph lauren, christian louboutin outlet, cheap oakley sunglasses, nike free, louis vuitton outlet, oakley sunglasses, louis vuitton outlet, nike air max, polo ralph lauren outlet online, gucci handbags, polo outlet, longchamp outlet, replica watches, ugg boots, louboutin pas cher, uggs on sale, burberry pas cher, louis vuitton, oakley sunglasses wholesale, longchamp outlet, sac longchamp pas cher, replica watches, chanel handbags, christian louboutin uk, nike roshe, air max, kate spade outlet, longchamp pas cher, nike outlet, christian louboutin shoes, oakley sunglasses, jordan shoes, louis vuitton, christian louboutin, tiffany and co, michael kors pas cher, louis vuitton outlet, oakley sunglasses, tiffany jewelry, tory burch outlet, ray ban sunglasses

oakleyses said...

polo lacoste, michael kors outlet online, nike air max uk, replica handbags, nike roshe run uk, uggs outlet, coach outlet, michael kors outlet online, sac vanessa bruno, oakley pas cher, ray ban pas cher, nike air max uk, lululemon canada, new balance, nike free uk, north face, nike air force, hogan outlet, kate spade, burberry outlet, mulberry uk, coach purses, true religion jeans, michael kors outlet online, abercrombie and fitch uk, michael kors outlet, hollister uk, converse pas cher, nike blazer pas cher, timberland pas cher, nike tn, true religion outlet, ralph lauren uk, michael kors, guess pas cher, sac hermes, michael kors outlet, ray ban uk, uggs outlet, michael kors outlet online, true religion outlet, coach outlet store online, michael kors, vans pas cher, true religion outlet, hollister pas cher, nike air max, michael kors outlet, north face uk